Skip to main content

The BUSKLAW November Newsletter: Dead Turkeys and Deader Tort Damages


November is the month of Thanksgiving. And Thanksgiving for most folks means time with family and friends (better yet, family who are friends), an appropriate but modestly-priced wine, and a turkey. Turkeys should live their brief sojourn on this earth in relative peace before winding up on our table. But that was not to be for the poor fowls in the recent Kent County (MI) Circuit Court case of White Acres, LLC et al v. Shur Green Farms, LLC et al. 

The case involves a plethora of parties (hence the "et al"), all of whom were in the distribution chain of a biofuel called Lascadoil. Unlike its parent product, Lasalocid, Lascadoil is not an appropriate turkey-feed additive. (Does anything with "oil" in its name sound fit for human or animal consumption?) So when a bunch of turkeys died after eating feed tainted with Lascadoil, the lawsuits started flying; each party was sued by its downstream buyer who in turn sued its upstream seller. And numerous insurance companies entered the fray.   

Before discussing the case itself, we need to talk about the differences between tort and contract claims. In the law, a tort is a civil wrong having the elements of duty, breach of duty, causation, and damages. Wrongful death is a common tort. For example, we go pheasant hunting, and I wave my loaded shotgun in your face. It discharges. You are killed entirely. Your estate sues me, alleging that I had a duty to handle my firearm safely. I breached that duty by discharging my loaded gun in your face which caused your death. And you (and your survivors) personally sustained damages because of my conduct; you're no longer around to give your family love and financial support. 

But torts are - and should be - unrelated to contracts, and the damages are different. Contract damages depend on a contract stating the parties' respective duties, a party breaches one or more of these duties, and the other party suffers damages as a result. But the damages are economic, i.e., you didn't get what you bargained for (money or something valuable). 

Even so, plaintiffs' trial lawyers are optimistic souls. They will argue anything if there's even a one percent chance that a court will agree. In the case at hand, they not only alleged breach of contract, but they also threw in several tort claims alleging negligence, intentional fraud, and "innocent misrepresentation." The defendants targeted with these negligence allegations asked Judge Christopher Yates to dismiss them under the economic loss doctrine, and he agreed.  

Judge Yates correctly found that the negligence claims couldn't stand because the economic loss doctrine bars tort recovery and limits remedies to those available under the Michigan Uniform Commercial Code where a claim for damages arises out of the commercial sale of goods and the losses are purely economic.  There is an exception for damages caused by fraud in the inducement (i.e., a defendant's fraud induced a plaintiff to sign a contract for the purchase of Lascadoil as a feed additive), but no one alleged that tort. The Court let stand breach of contract claims, including breach of implied warranty, so the case will now continue on that basis.

Calculating probable damages in contract disputes can be tricky. You need an experienced team consisting of a competent lawyer (who isn't litigating the matter), an accountant, and risk manager to perform an accurate analysis. But alleging tort damages in a breach of contract case will likely get those allegations thrown out of court  - and may earn you the judge's disrespect in the process.
  ____________________________________

If you find this post worthwhile, please consider sharing it with your colleagues. The link to this blog is www.busklaw.blogspot.com and my website is www.busklaw.com. And my email address is busklaw@charter.net. Thanks! 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The BUSKLAW April Newsletter: On the Foolish Tension Between Lawyers and Business Folks

From my colleague Mark Grossman   comes this joke (just in time for April Fool's Day): A man in a hot air balloon is lost. He reduces the balloon's height and spots a man below. He shouts, "Excuse me, can you tell me where I am?" The man below says: "Yes, you're in a hot air balloon hovering at 30 feet." " You must be a lawyer," says the balloonist. "I am," replies the man. "How did you know?" "Well," says the balloonist, "everything you have told me is technically correct, but useless." The man below says, "You must work in business." "I do," replies the balloonist, "but how did you know?" "Well," says the lawyer, "you don't know where you are, or where you're going, but you expect me to be able to help. You're in the same position you were before we met, but now it's my fault." ______________________________________...

The BUSKLAW November Newsletter: About the U.S. Army's Extraterrestrial Technology Acquisition Contract!

This post would appear to be a Halloween prank, but it isn't. On October 10, 2019, the U.S. Army Combat Capabilities Development Command signed a contract [or in government parlance, a Cooperative Research and Development Agreement (CRADA)] with To the Stars Academy of Arts and Science, Inc. for the acquisition of the latter's ET(?) technology. The entire contract is available here , but I'll save you from the content that isn't worth your time.   But first some history. Once there was a punk rock group called Blink 182 , founded by Tom DeLonge. Tom eventually became more enthused about UFOs than rock music and decided to seriously study unexplained aerial phenomena (UAP). He claims to have formed relationships with top government officials to eventually disclose to the public what's behind UAP. In the meantime, Tom formed a public corporation, To the Stars Academy (TSA), to be a "revolutionary collaboration between academia, industry and pop culture to a...

The BUSKLAW January Newsletter: Catching Typographical Errors in Contracts

“Career Path” is an overused term to describe how we should conduct our professional lives to reach our full potential. In my experience, most self-help books on this subject assume that we have more control over our lives than we actually do. The old adage, “Man proposes, God disposes,” is not evident in these books. And yet there are ways for contracts lawyers to reach their full potential - how about by catching those pesky typographical errors ("typos")?  Is there anything more rewarding to a contracts lawyer than catching a typographical error? Of course not. I once did a long and complicated real estate license agreement, only to have my client point out the fact that on page 39, section 1, paragraph A, subsection (i), clause (z) of the contract I drafted, the word “thee” should be “the.” I can’t tell you enough about the warm fuzzy feeling that this observation created in the depths of my soul!  At best, typographical errors are embarrassing and have only...